preview

Comparing Two Historical Films Essay

Good Essays

The Compare and Contrast of Two Historical Films
When the Sun was A God and With Fire and Sword are two films directed by Jerzy Hoffman, respectively in 2003 and 1999. The films were based on the historical events, illustrating the common matters of individuals’ desire to overpower others with wealth, power, and control in order to take over the throne and land. Both films took place in different settings – Piast dynasty era and Khmelnytsky Uprising era – but they do share some similarities and differences. The reason for why I chose these two films to compare and contrast was due to the fact that they share certain aspects that set the films alike and apart from one another. The aspects are: greed, friendship, loyalty, women, and love.
The first aspect that arose in these two films is greed. Greed was described fairly well in the films through Popiel and Bohdan Khmelnytsky. Although the characters were placed in different centuries, the films did not fail …show more content…

Firstly, there was Dwiza, the main character of the film. She has the artless image as a woman, living up to the fact that she was given to God as a child and has a duty. Secondly, the other type of woman was Dwiza’s mother. Her mother was responsible in taking care of the things that went on at home and taking care of her children. She was a strict woman and was frequently at the aid of her husband. Lastly, there was Mila. Mila represented the image of an attractive woman. Her character was the type that appeals to men. In comparison with With Fire and Sword to When the Sun was A God, Princess Helena and her aunt shared similar features as Mila and Dwiza’s mother. Princess Helena was also an eye-catching woman, despite the fact that she was fragile. As for Princess Helena’s aunt, she was much stricter compare to Dwiza’s mother as she was the head of her

Get Access